Who has the best burger in Vail? It’s a question that sparks debate among locals, après-ski regulars, and summer hikers alike. In a town celebrated for fine dining and alpine luxury, it’s often the simple comfort of a perfectly crafted burger that leaves the strongest impression.
From juicy half-pound creations dripping with Colorado cheddar to wagyu sliders paired with craft cocktails, Vail’s burger scene is as diverse as its terrain. This review dives into seven of the most talked-about spots, weighing flavor, atmosphere, and value to uncover which burger truly deserves the crown.
1. Sweet Basil – The Elevated Classic
Sweet Basil, one of Vail’s most iconic restaurants, is better known for its contemporary American cuisine and fine dining appeal. Yet tucked into its menu lies a burger that locals whisper about: the Sweet Basil Burger, a carefully composed dish layered with aged cheddar, house pickles, and a brioche bun that rivals any steakhouse entrée.
- Atmosphere: Upscale, lively, and perfect for foodies.
- Burger highlight: Premium beef blend, balanced with tangy pickles and smoky aioli.
- Best for: Those who want a burger that feels like fine dining.
This isn’t a grab-and-go bite—it’s an indulgent take on an American staple, paired best with a glass of red wine or a local IPA.
2. Bully Ranch – The Western Legend
Inside the Sonnenalp Hotel, Bully Ranch has built a reputation for hearty comfort food that feels like home after a long day on the mountain. Their Bully Burger is a robust, no-frills option: thick patty, fresh toppings, and the option to load it with bacon or chili.
- Atmosphere: Rustic Western vibe with leather booths.
- Burger highlight: A build-your-own style that satisfies traditionalists.
- Best for: Families or groups who want hearty portions in a casual setting.
Regulars call it a “cowboy’s dream,” and it delivers every time—especially when paired with their signature mudslide cocktail.
3. Root & Flower – The Gourmet Surprise
Known primarily as a wine bar, Root & Flower isn’t the first place one expects to find a burger worth writing about. Yet their house wagyu burger has become a local insider secret. Served with truffle aioli and a perfectly toasted bun, it’s a boutique version of comfort food.
- Atmosphere: Chic, intimate, and modern.
- Burger highlight: Wagyu beef with luxe accompaniments.
- Best for: Date nights or après-ski foodies.
For many, this burger proves that sometimes the most unexpected menus hold the biggest delights.
4. Vendetta’s – The Late-Night Favorite
For decades, Vendetta’s has been the go-to spot for pizza and après, but locals insist the burger deserves equal recognition. Juicy, affordable, and served late into the night, it’s become the fuel of ski patrollers and night-shift workers.
- Atmosphere: Bustling, casual, and quintessentially Vail.
- Burger highlight: Straightforward patty, generous toppings, and fries that actually satisfy.
- Best for: Late-night cravings after a day on the slopes.
While it may not be as refined as Sweet Basil’s, Vendetta’s burger earns its spot on the list for authenticity and consistency.
5. The Remedy Bar – The Scenic Showstopper
Inside the Four Seasons, The Remedy Bar delivers not only one of the best views in town but also a burger that feels like an event. Their Remedy Burger is built with Colorado beef, sharp cheddar, and smoky bacon, then elevated by a side of truffle fries.
- Atmosphere: Upscale lounge with mountain views.
- Burger highlight: Rich flavors enhanced by perfect fries.
- Best for: Luxury travelers or après-ski celebrations.
It’s the kind of burger that pairs perfectly with champagne—a rare find in ski country.
6. Garfinkel’s – The Après Essential
Perched slopeside in Lionshead, Garfinkel’s has been a longtime après-ski institution. The Garf’s Burger is straightforward but satisfying: juicy patty, melted American cheese, and a pile of golden fries.
- Atmosphere: Loud, social, and full of ski boots.
- Burger highlight: Affordable, satisfying après-ski fuel.
- Best for: Groups who want a lively, no-fuss meal.
It may not win awards for creativity, but Garf’s burger earns its reputation as the essential après bite.
7. The Red Lion – The Local Hero
The Red Lion is practically synonymous with Vail après-ski culture, and its burger holds legendary status among locals. Served in generous portions with a choice of toppings, it’s hearty enough to satisfy even the hungriest skier.
- Atmosphere: Classic après-ski bar with live music.
- Burger highlight: Generous, juicy portions with customizable flair.
- Best for: Skiers who want a classic Vail tradition on a plate.
It’s not just a burger—it’s part of the Red Lion experience, complete with beer, live music, and a sense of community.
Who Really Has the Best Burger in Vail?
So, who has the best burger in Vail? The answer depends on the diner:
- For luxury seekers: Sweet Basil or The Remedy Bar.
- For families: Bully Ranch.
- For late-night bites: Vendetta’s.
- For après-ski crowds: Garfinkel’s or The Red Lion.
- For foodies: Root & Flower’s wagyu creation.
Ultimately, the title isn’t fixed—it shifts depending on what a traveler values most: sophistication, tradition, affordability, or atmosphere.
FAQs: Who Has The Best Burger In Vail
1. What is the most popular burger spot in Vail?
The Red Lion and Garfinkel’s are among the most popular, thanks to their après-ski culture and generous portions.
2. Where can you find the most upscale burger in Vail?
Sweet Basil and The Remedy Bar both serve elevated versions that combine fine dining with comfort food.
3. Which burger is best for families?
Bully Ranch offers hearty, customizable options in a family-friendly setting.
4. Is there a late-night burger option in Vail?
Yes. Vendetta’s is a reliable choice for burgers served late into the night.
5. Do any Vail restaurants serve wagyu burgers?
Yes. Root & Flower has a wagyu burger with truffle aioli that’s become a foodie favorite.
Conclusion
The Vail Valley may be known for fine dining and après-ski champagne, but when it comes to burgers, the competition is just as fierce. From luxury wagyu creations to late-night classics, the contenders reflect the diversity of the town itself.
So the next time the question arises—“Who has the best burger in Vail?”—the answer may be less about one winner and more about matching the burger to the moment.
Planning your Vail getaway? Don’t miss our guides on the best hotels in Vail and the best restaurants in Vail to round out your stay.
Summary (TL;DR)
This guide explores who has the best burger in Vail by reviewing seven standout spots. From Sweet Basil’s elevated fine-dining take to Garfinkel’s après essential, the choices range from upscale to casual. The best burger depends on what you’re after—luxury, affordability, atmosphere, or tradition.
